Comparison

Fractional, agency, or full-time?

The short answer

Hire an agency when you know what to build and need a large team to build it for a long time. Hire a full-time head of product when product is a permanent, full-week leadership job and you can recruit for it. Bring in a fractional head of product when you need senior judgment on what to build and why now, for less than a full-time executive. With agentic AI tools, I can also design and build much of it myself, scoped per project.

By Walter Colindres Updated
Fractional head of productDigital agencyFull-time hire
Main jobDecide what to build and why; lead the team and stakeholdersDesign and build what you've decidedDecide, lead and build the organization, every day
Best whenYou need senior judgment now, or between leadersThe roadmap is clear and you need capacityProduct is permanent, full-week work
Time to startWeeksWeeksMonths to recruit
CostMonthly retainer (mine starts at $6,000/mo)Project or team fees, usually tied to build scopeSalary, bonus, equity and benefits
Accountable forOutcomes: conversion, revenue, retentionDelivery: the scope you agreedOutcomes and the team, long term
Can it also build?Mine can: Design & Build, scoped per project, using AI tools and trusted partnersYes, that's the main jobThrough the team they hire and run
Watch out forLarge, long-running builds still need a teamBuilds what you ask for, even if it's the wrong thingSlow and costly to get wrong

When I'm the wrong choice

When I'm the right one

Questions people ask

What’s the difference between a fractional head of product and an agency?

An agency designs and builds what you ask for. A fractional head of product decides what to build, in what order and why, and is accountable for the result. Many brands need both.

When is a full-time head of product the better choice?

When product is a permanent, full-week leadership job, the team is large enough to need a leader every day, and you can recruit for it.

Can a fractional head of product help us hire a full-time one?

Yes. Defining the role, interviewing candidates and handing over a working roadmap and team is a common way to end a fractional engagement.

Not sure where to start?

30 minutes. No deck. Just an honest conversation about where you are and what’s in the way.

Let's talk